I hope you don't mind me making an 'official' topic :P. You can take the official part out if ya want. Anyway, I noticed you guys didn't have a topic like this so I decided to post it.

Basically, some who posts under me rates my signature on a scale of 10 (with 10/10 being best). And then another person rates the person who posted last, and keep rating the person who posted above you.

Kay, let the Rating of the Signatures start!

8/10 Very nice! ^^; I like it.

4/10
umm. . . it just needs more. . .

7/10
A good quote, lacks substance

4/10
Silence, you are certainly not one to speak of substance. I do like the text, but it could use something more.

Feel free to rate my sig, anyone, but do notice that I change it quite often.

7/10 (the King Slime .gif)

I like how it's not packing a lot of images in there, and by that I mean more than one, but perhaps an unforgetable quote would raise the rating? (the anal Wand of Cure Light Wounds?)

8/10

Excellent quote at the end, the other two could be offensive, but are funny anyway. Not very visually spectacular, but that's not always a bad thing.

9.5/10

I like the image
I like the song
I like the book
I like the movie
I'm not a fan of the game
The CD scares me
The two sayings just don't fit

Near: The sayings are both from Church's chicken commercials

10/10

Psychedelic.

7/10 - Sorry, but I'm not a generous judge. The "DO NOT . . . " things . . . are not funny, even to those of those who knew of their origin . . . I hate Church's Chicken anyway . . . the image is pretty good, but it looks unprofessionally, specifically in the way the figure is being cut off. The lyrics . . . The Faint is pwnage, that's all I've got to say. The "currently" list at the bottom is okay, but I often find myself having to disagree with your tastes. Lastly, a minor suggestion. The image may look better if centered. Also, you might want to throw in some different font colors.

10/10
Good references all around. I enjoy the King Slime, as well as the quotes. A good precident for our Chief Member.

5/10

Um, good quote, but odd image. I get it's saying no music (as in silence, right?), but it doesn't seem belonging to be...

9/10

I like the image, and agree with several of your "Currently" list (I don't read, however, and I'm not waiting for N/A.) I don't know the song, but it looks cool.

*Random number between one and four*/10
not enough there

7/10 That weird looking sig thing is cool, but sorta plain after awhile.

8/10 - Decent already, but doesn't really 'click'. Appears kind of mishmashed, or . . . something. One change I would make is changing your line of dashes to appear the same as the white one that seperates your post from your sig in terms of color and length to make it all appear more uniform. It may also be more attractive if the upper image is centered, but I would have to see it both ways to judge. Lastly, your final bit of text is a big ambiguous. Still, one of the better sigs we see around here, so I offered a nice eight. It may have been a nine, but I get kind of tired of always seeing the same sig. Perhaps it would be a good idea to change it more frequently, at least making minor alterations, like I do with mine, rather than changing the whole thing at once.


My main reason for posting now is to get some feedback about my updated sig (notice the 'hidden' link).




edit ~ Sorry, but another note for Sephy®: Your larger image tends to stretch things out when on certain resolutions.

The link doesn't work at school, but I like the different coloring of quotes as well as the actual quotes themselves. I'd say 9-10/10

I like the skeleton, but I think I've said that before. It would look better non-cut-off, but the image is good. The song is interesting, but I don't know the tune so it's hard to critique its overall goodness. The quote is funny, and the 'Currently' thing is cool, even if Tekken 5 is the only thing on it I recognize.

oooh! I love necroposting!

This signature is pretty funny, but not toward my tastes. The text is pretty much boring and the focus of the picture being do far on the left side creats a slight imbalance. Overall, 7/10

I like the picture, but your text is fairly hard to read. The date you have, according to your recent post is incorrect.

I really posted here to see what poeple thought of my first real attempt at animation. I made it in photoshop-imageready.

I've seen better. It's much easier to do that kinda stuff in Flash. X3