OK I think we all want to know this.

Strongest form of Inuyasha would tear Ed apart before he could move.

I agree.

Hm... two of the best characters in the uni... Ed, he pulls a :scar: on Inu and blows his face up.

Oh, and the getting torn apart thing: Ed turns the ground around himself into a shield, and then does said face blowing up.

Ed would win.

Inuyasha walked through the forest, hands stuffed into his kimono.
"Why are we going this way anyways?" He complained, looking back at Kagome. "Kagome?!" He yelled, discovering she wasn't there.

Edward Elric walked through the dense forest of the island, swatting away overgrown plants with his automail.
"Dammit.. Al give me a hand!" He yelled, turning to look at his younger brother. "AL?!" He yelled, seeing that he wasn't there.

The two confused guys smacked into each and both yelled out in suprise.
Inuyasha whipped out his fang. "Who are you?!"
Ed stared at him, automail transformed already into a deadly dagger. "Edward Elric!" He yelled. "You?"
Inuyasha glared at him."Inuyasha!"

Edward started to lower his arm. "I'm leaving." He said, starting to turn.
"Hey, shorty!" yelled Inuyasha, shealthing his sword. "Have you seen a---"
"DON'T CALL ME SHORT!" Ed screamed, running towards Inuyasha with the blade of his automail out.
Inuyasha jumped backwards, drawing his own weapon. "Dammit." He rushed at the boy, swinging the sword wildly at him.
Ed clapped his hands together and slammed them onto the ground.

A large glow surronded the dog-demon, blinding him for a moment.
Edward aimed and threw the long spear at the dog boy, piercing his shoulder.
"Augh!" Inuyasha jumped back, yanking the spear out and feeling himself get dizzy a bit. His fang fell from the injured arm and to the ground. "Damn! The little bastard got my sword arm."
Ed ran towards Inuyasha, his automail arm smacking the other arm as it reached down to pick up the sword.
Inuyasha let out a suprised scream and withdrew backwards. The other arm felt numb.
"Damn." Inuyasha turned backwards and started running, trying to think properly. The sword hung loosely in his other arm, but just barely. Not enough to actually use it properly.

Ed watched as the dog-demon ran off.
"What a strange guy." He thought out loud.
"Brother! Who was that?!" Al asked, staring at the disappearing form of Inuyasha.
"I don't really know." Ed said with a sigh and turned. "Let's go."

There.
It's even logical if you think about it.
Inuyasha wouldn't just randomly run up to someone and kill them. Ed would try to kill someone if they called him short and if Al wasn't around. It makes sense too. Ed gives a quick distraction by using some alchemy to pull a spear out of the ground, and then used it to render Inuyasha's sword arm useless. Then he rushes towards him while Inuyasha's trying to get the sword and pierces the other shoulder blade. Inuyasha runs off, knowing he can't use the sword at the moment.



You also have to realize that they are from different animes, so each one has a different perspective of strength.

You forgot about Inuyasha's endurance and his red cloak.

Well here's the issue. Your forgetting about the difference in power of the two in their shows.
Ed is like an Inuyasha in his show and Inuyasha is like an Ed in his show. You can't compare the two, it just doesn't really work out that well.

And plus, the cloak of the Fire Rat isn't invincible, that's already been proved on the thousands of occassions the dumbass has gotten stabbed through. I'm sure that if a simple katana can pierce it on a good through, then Ed's automail can do the same. And also, the endurance part.... I mean, come on. Inuyasha wasn't killed or exhausted, he ran off because he was smart enough((Oh my gosh, he's SMART?!)) to figure out that both of his arms weren't going to be working properly enough to fight. I don't know about you but that sword looks pretty damn heavy to me, and if both of your arms have just gotten their nerves a good shook I think you'd consider running too.

And if your going to bring back a defense, at least bring back a good one. Not just,

Ed is smart. Inuyasha is dumb. He just is. There's nothing else that can compare with his stupidity. Except maybe my Kouga's stupidity, but even Kouga is smarter than the mutt. He's not stupid, just very stubborn in love. ANYWAYS...

If your going to say that Inuyasha can win, then actually give some proof and a whole act. Not just, he can rip him up wit one slahs

Hm, I think Ed wouold win, though it would probably be close.

It would be a draw

Inuyasha would win.

Ha Ha! All this talk of fanficton fights has got me giddy. Well to determine a winner I would have to go through the battle in my head but since I'm too lazy right now I'll make an educated guess. It depends on what range they are fighting in. At close range yes Ed would in because he's much better with his weapons and martial arts. But at long range Inuyasha all the way! I seriously doubt Ed could dodge and or block a barrage of Kaze no Kizus and Kongousouhas. Eventually one would connect and it would be over.