One for SURE. They're very good.

One.

4, because 1's forum team sucks. I dun liek Hawkeye. If it didn't, I'd probably be unable to choose between 4 and 1.

I like 3's root admin though. Only thing that sucks about these in general is that no one used dragon riders :(

Damn...they're all pretty good.

Either #1 or #2.

A choice between Marcus or Hawkeye in Set#1, though? Baaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaad. :angry:

Number one does nothing for me. Wait, they make me feel slightly ill.

Four are great though. Way beyond the others.

Marcus ownz joo n00b.
:boom:

Only in FE6 Hard mode. But I gladly digress... I like two, I didn't like the representations in 1. Members as Generals? Okay, aren't Generals immensely powerful, albeit horribly slow?

I voted for four.

*Points out that my group will still have an animated myrmidon either way*

2, 1 Hurts my eyes, and I don't like the streaks in 4.

1 is also WAY to busy.

3 is just plain WTF?

Hmm... I like two.

Two. One is amazing, but two fits the forum more appropriatly.

Cons
#1: BG=Wayyy too busy for member icons.
#2: Good, but absolutely HORRIBLE text.
#3: Too boring
#4: Streaks

Pros
#1: Professional looking
#2: Everything else
#3: um...pretty colors?
#4: Same as #2


I just hope we get #2 or #4. I voted for #4.

#1 Good backs and fonts, but bad choice of units
#2 I hate that text so bad...and the unit choices as well.
#3 boring backs, but again the text, and the colorings. Like root admin though.
#4 Hmmm...streaky is ok...but it isn't appealing in some way...

I voted 1...perhaps with the units from four would be perfect.

I just saw something.

All of the Forum Team icons suck except for #4.

I don't want Hawkeye. He's a pansy.
I don't want Pent/Louise. Too weak.
I don't want Legault. We want signs of Power, not stealth.
I don't especially want Wallace either, but at least he it's a sign of Power.

4 is just the best. no questions asked. *silences question askers*

They're all pretty good, but I wish the was more creative characters used in the selection. :/ Some customized sprites would of been cool or at least specialized classes such as the "Seal", "Necromancer", Zypher(whatever his class was) and such. Other than that those are beyond anything I can handel at the moment.

I think they all kind of suck.

Same here. I don't think any of them stand out that well. Pondy don't bash on all the ones that weren't made by you; you didn't even use all the right colors. I'm not voting.

I do like 3 or 4 the best, since my vote for 3 won't do anything, I vote 4.

Yay! Tie-breaking vote!

Um, why the hell are YOU complaining? All the G-Mods suck. #4 doesn't even have one, but the roy mod is cool enough. #2 is good, except the GM one (Lucius looks like crap).

I vote for #2. Those are just awesome! I like the filters. They are way better than the ones I made XD.

Lmao @ Pondy saying all of the forum team icons suck except for his...

ALL yours suck Pondy. :/ IMO atleast.

I don't like 3's much either.

2's are really good, the font kinda kills them. They're my second favorite though.

1's are good, not amazing or anything, but overall I'd prefer them by a small amount over 2.

I voted #1, but #4 was my second.

The admin and the root admin one are kick ass in #4 and you all know it.

Can I add a suggestion?

Maybe--since people like certain icons more than others in a group--maybe different icons from each group can be used...?

Example: Veteran from group 2; Root Admin from group 4; Admin from group 3; G-mod from group 1... And etc. Understand what I'm talking about?

They need to match though =\

I like 4, but they all rock pretty hard.

I like 2 the most, overall.

Pondy's don't exactly fit this layout very well. :unsure:

And Taoma's do?

Good point. I say you DQ both. :P

One.


The rest suck horrificly.

One is too busy for a mostly relaxed forum.

We have more to think about here than quality, it is a factor, but I'd rather see something that reflects the board as a whole.

Professional, but to a extent, THAT is the FEW I've come to know and love.

I don't think any of the two that shouldn't be DQ'd fit the board that well. Re-contest?

Hey, what the hell? I didn't say anything about your crapy icons. <_<

Okay, all that don't follow the format are automatically disqualified. Vote on the ones that are left. Simple.

And don't mind Pondy. He hates it when people don't think he's the best.

~Crystal

I dun really like any of them. :(

I resisted voting one; I wanted to laugh at Alex, Karn and 'Ivan for having Mrcus as their avatars, but I'm too nice. :P So, I voted four.

Lets just stop the contest and make a new one so that more people can enter and so you can lay more rules down on how you guys want them to be like so they match the forum better. Wouldn't that be better than having only 4 to choose from and none of them even matching? ^_^

I like that idea. Now what they know what we all want, the graphic arts can do a better job. (not saying they aren't great to begin with)