Well, I'm interested in knowing what all of you think of the reset. Any complaints? Suggestion? Complements?

Complaints:

Judges judge only their own matches, or require fees to judge. Arbitors as well.
Stats are slightly skewed.

Suggestions:
Make judges judge others matches before their own/
Actual LEVEL CAPS according to other players MAIN charcter.

Compliments:
Well thought out, but could've been executed a tad better.

About the judges, wasn't there that "Judging Day"?

What happened to that?

I havn't seen it.

And I've had stuff sitting in the arena for a week.

Judges don't even get paid unless they judge other peoples battles. Judging day should be brought back, if it isn't here anymore.

Let me re-phrase a pervious comment.

Judges only judge their own COUNTRIES fights/their own.

Same complaint as always: It's not even. Everyone goes to one place right off the bat and the monopolize the judges. What do I suggest? Throw all the names of members who wish to join the stat RPG into a "hat". Then draw out the names randomly, giving each country equal amounts of members. Before someone starts bitching at me about this, it's at least an idea.

Strikey's got a point, most people are born into the country they live in... so wouldn't it make sense if we didn't have a choice where we joined, aside from the leaders?

Yeah so?
If you want to, you can move yourself out, no biggee

Then theres always the complaint of why did i get this noob who joined and left when he got 3 active arbitors, and if your going to pit people against their friends, no one will want to play and will cause FEW to eventually die

Way to pick a few judges out of the crowd :D way to go man :angry:
Just because some people do that doesn't mean ALL judges do that, i'll judge for anyone if i'm not busy

I'd agree with that, it's kinda awkward, not sure how to explain it, just hard to verbalize it xD

How/Why, if you do, couldn't someone judge one of their country member matches, and then judge all of theirs xD

Why would all the charcters have a level cap based on one of their characters, and some people don't have a "main", unless you mean the character made first, which still aren't always the strongest

For Real, i mean what's with the no promo bosses? Seesh :lol:

Personally, I think the new RPG is very well thought-out. Sure, it has it's flukes, but so does everything else in the world!

Personally, I enjoy it, especially the new made up countries. I'm quite anxious to see what plot twists are in store for us. I really like the revolt idea, cause I know someone is going to do it and shock their leaders. The judging thing is of course, a valid point, but thats the way they feel. I would like to see special events though, perhaps monster invasions, or mysterious wars.

Overall, I'd give the new FEW Rpg, an 8 out of 10.

EDIT--Here's a suggestion. A forge for any and all chars to upgrade normal level weapons like iron up and down by weight, power, and critical, like FE9. I'm sure someone can figure the rates out.

My only big complant is that theres no neutral shops for the unaffilated to buy new weapons.

UB, you also have to remember all the judges that I pointed out have literally no lives, unlike the rest of the judges.

All members buy weapons from what country they reside in, not serve.

Mix, you also have to remember I didn't see your list of the judges that you pointed out, and the literally do have a life, like the rest of the judges

Copy-Cat Game Fun!

I'm Aien, dummy.

And, If your on the internet longer than me, then you have no life.

That, or, we have nothing better to do.

I know, you and mix act almost exactly the same, and you change you name alot, so i just call you both mix xD

UB, that is easily the STUPIDEST comparison I've ever heard in my life, Mixtil's name has actually ALWAYS been mixtil...

And Luis, sadly enough, what you said, is exactly what Aien said. Not having anything better to do = not having a life pretty much...

honestly, I much preferred the previous set-up. the title/effective weapons/promoted-stat-caps-for-crying-out-loud system seems much saner than this chaos. no offense to every/anyone who worked on it, but for all the time it took for the reset, this whole RPG looks quite threadbare. I expected something much more in-depth than this whilst I waited.

Not really, I could have had plans, but due to events (such as cancellation and whatnot), I may not be able to go.

Complaints: Same as Aien and Strike MOST judges dont give a damn about others that arent in thier own country. And we have to pay them at least 100 gold for each battle to get thier attention. I know I know that judge day thing i only got about 3 battle judged that day and i have had stuff lying around longer than 3 weeks and those eldoltian battle topics and the saylem one no one from other countries have been judged they put thier own country in the priority and leave the others to rot and wait for at least another 5 weeks.

Suggestions: Distribute the judges evenly into countries or at least give them all a list of battles that need judging and tell them not to put thier own countries or thier own battles in priority. I have made a fuss about my battles (my avatar message the link in my sig the support quote on lades's sig hint hint) and still not one judged yet and its not only me its ryetsi and lades as well I know you all have lives but you alway seem to have time to judges your own topics and allways have time to judge your own countries battles but when it comes down to someone else's battles you are all ways tired busy or something came up.

Complemants: It is a very well thought out and the RP is some what fun. The countries are placed and all.

(quote=ReyDeMagival)

Actually, no. :ph43r: It was T1psy_3lf_04 for about a week once for a joke. Horrendous joke.


Opinion of current RPG: It's not the second RPG. 'Nuff said.

Yeah, I remember that... really bad joke, but I was saying... you've only changed your name once.

Oh, I see.

In my eyes, they seem the same, if its just me, fair enough. and I said i call Aien "Mixtil", and Mixtil "Mixtil" <.< please read before you try to chew me out please?

So your saying treat the judges as cattle and herd them around to the countries? If so, your freaking nuts, why would we want to get thrown around everywhere?

What if they can't judge for a reason? Ban them? And all that will lead to most likely someone will have people get mad at them, and it could be because someone died, or they were sick, so they couldn't be on...

Thats proablly the reason, your having a fuss about someone not judging, why not be a judge yourself and judge it, most will likely not want to judge for someone whose getting mad at them...

Okay, want to know why some of the judges, including me became a judge? Because no-one would judge for us, so we had to go and be a judge just so we cna get our battles done, and your getting mad at us for that? <_<

Mabey cause we make the time to judge, i'm usually tired all the time so i just judge myself when i'm half-awake or w/e, and then i'll talk on MSN and go to bed, it just adds up and makes it harder if you get like 8 PMs a day asking to judge thier battles


So, here's my random thought :lol: :
Either become a judge yourself and judge your battles, or get over it >.>

DONT DRAG ME INTO THIS!!!*even if it's true*

But, I actually have taken the judging test already, and am just waiting on my results from Pondy, from FRIDAY(or was it thursday? Saturday?)...

But judges can't judge their own topics, can they? I thought only Arbitors could.

You can, but you need to get the random numbers from another judge, and you have to post the random numbers you use...

EDIT: UB, stop being an asshole. Kakashi has a point. It's the judge's JOB to judge OTHER PEOPLE's battles, not his own. You're given the ability to judge your own through the "mercy" or "grace" of the administration, and that ability isn't there to be abused, which judges today seem to love doing. Whether you became a judge to judge your own battles is your problem, but the judge's JOB is to judge OTHERS' battles...

I disagree, Reyde. It isn't anyone's "job" to judge somebody else's battle. It's true that it is nice to judge your own battles, but if the admin took that away, it doesn't mean that those judges would start judging other people's. We can't force them to do it either. Sometimes, Judges have a thing they call a life, and they just can't get to it...

UB, I have to say that may have been a little harsh. Maybe they need a dose of reality, but that no reason to yell at them.

If your waiting for your judge response, KEEP WAITING! Pondy and Ultima are only two people who have to judge all of these test. Counting me, Lades, and Ryetsi; that's three different people for Pondy alone. Admittedly it seems to be since Friday for all of us, Again the thing called a life needs to be taken care of first. Just keep waiting and I'm sure he'll get back to you sooner or later...

No longer for me, Sirjohn, I passed my test. Through the power of Ultima, I am now a judge!

The point of a judge is to judge battles between two players fairly. So technically, it is ideal for a judge to judge battles that aren't his or her own, which ideally removes bias. So it pretty much is the judge's job. It's what they get paid for. You don't actually get paid for judging your own battles.

This may be true but the amount of time it takes to judge a battle, isn't worth 50 gold. That more like a tip than payment. About the bias? That why we get random numbers from others. Thus, there is no way to cheat.

Please be kidding? no way it's our job to judge others' battle, it's just something we do >.>

We were given the ability because the administration is too lazy and busy to do it themselves, not because we begged for it...

We're not abusing it.... we're judging battles, please tell me how that's abusing...

Once again, it is not our job, we're not supposed to judge others people's battles only, which alot of people are trying to make us do

How was that harsh, I didn't curse or anything (I think, i may be wrong though) , and yes they do ^_^ , and i wasn't yelling, and even if i was, you couldn't hear it, i was typing, heck i wasn't even typing in caps...

Once again, if any admin sees this, i will GLADLY do this alswell, and be much faster then them since i don't have any admin dutys to also work with

Exactly, and we are, besides those who are judging their own mirror battles, which always besides like twice i think, they won, which including criticaling out of nowhere, somehow having the mirror to miss everytime, and their characters ALWAYS attack first, now before you accuse me, look at my mirrors, i have never once judged my own battle as far as i can remember, which is why i think the mirror forum schould be taken off becuase THAT is the only thing abused

So what your saying we're cheating? :hopping: Not even man...I'll just stop there before i go too far....

:blink: Oops..., I sorry, That not what I wantted it to sound like. :( Ijust meant that it sounded as though you were angry at them when they were just posting there opinions.

:D , No need to be sorry....I've been pissed lately, we had this big racist ordeal at school, and was manly targetted at me and my friend, it was really annoying, being a white kid in a mexican dominated school in USA is really werid and tough, and i'm not angry at their opinions, it's just that mine and his seem to be inverted, and i'm just speaking my side of it xD

...but you are Mexican.

xD, not everyone knows that, matter of fact, more people on FEW know that then at my school xD, only my best friends know because they've been to my house. 'Sides, i'm white skinned, and i've told you that thousands of times xD

D'you remember Western Lycia, and how they all owned beacuse they had soooooo many incredibly active judges?

Maybe jusges shouldn't judge their nations battles.

Read it again before you get into a heated argument with me... seriously. You missed the point of my post ENTIRELY. You have a habit of doing that... especially with me for some reason.

About the "no life" thing... staffers normally shouldn't have a life because if they did then nothing would get done. XD

I like this reset much better than the last RPG version. The percentages are more efficient than the "good, poor, average" deal and the fact that you took out the keywords is an added plus.

My only problem is that not many people post on new characeters. I've been posting there telling people if they had miscalculations in their profiles, but I don't see anyone else doing it. Plus, none of the staffers have done any of that and it's their job (the RPG staffers, anyway). I, for one, would like it if the RPG staff would be a little more on-the-ball in that particular forum because it's frustrarting not to be able to level up a new character.

I am in no way trying to offend the staff. I'm merely voicing my opinon.