Title: Muslim Congressman Ownz Critics
Severian - January 4, 2007 04:26 AM (GMT)
Keith Ellison, who is America's first Muslim congressman, wanted to swear an oath on
his holy book, the Qoran. Apparently some of our other politicians didn't like that much. Sooo....they got
OWNED| QUOTE |
But It's Thomas Jefferson's Koran!
By Amy Argetsinger and Roxanne Roberts Wednesday, January 3, 2007; C03
Rep.-elect Keith Ellison, the first Muslim elected to Congress, found himself under attack last month when he announced he'd take his oath of office on the Koran -- especially from Virginia Rep. Virgil Goode, who called it a threat to American values.
Yet the holy book at tomorrow's ceremony has an unassailably all-American provenance. We've learned that the new congressman -- in a savvy bit of political symbolism -- will hold the personal copy once owned by Thomas Jefferson.
"He wanted to use a Koran that was special," said Mark Dimunation, chief of the rare book and special collections division at the Library of Congress, who was contacted by the Minnesota Dem early in December. Dimunation, who grew up in Ellison's 5th District, was happy to help.
Jefferson's copy is an English translation by George Sale published in the 1750s; it survived the 1851 fire that destroyed most of Jefferson's collection and has his customary initialing on the pages. This isn't the first historic book used for swearing-in ceremonies -- the Library has allowed VIPs to use rare Bibles for inaugurations and other special occasions.
Ellison will take the official oath of office along with the other incoming members in the House chamber, then use the Koran in his individual, ceremonial oath with new Speaker Nancy Pelosi. "Keith is paying respect not only to the founding fathers' belief in religious freedom but the Constitution itself," said Ellison spokesman Rick Jauert.
One person unlikely to be swayed by the book's illustrious history is Goode, who released a letter two weeks ago objecting to Ellison's use of the Koran. "I believe that the overwhelming majority of voters in my district would prefer the use of the Bible," the Virginia Republican told Fox News, and then went on to warn about what he regards as the dangers of Muslims immigrating to the United States and Muslims gaining elective office.
Yeah, but what about a Koran that belonged to one of the greatest Virginians in history? Goode, who represents Jefferson's birthplace of Albemarle County, had no comment yesterday. |
EDIT:
Another somewhat interesting article for good measure.
Some random bloggerEDIT2:
Maybe Goode won't get
too owned, because Keith's a nice guy:
(from wiki)
| QUOTE |
In a New York Times interview Ellison said Goode "seemed ill informed about his personal origins as well as about Constitutional protections of religious freedom. 'I’m not an immigrant. I’m an African-American.' ...I’m not a religious scholar, I’m a politician, and I do what politicians do, which is hopefully pass legislation to help the nation.'" He said "he planned to focus on secular issues like increasing the federal minimum wage and getting health insurance for the uninsured."[23] Ellison continued “I’m looking forward to making friends with Representative Goode, or at least getting to know him. I want to let him know that there’s nothing to fear. The fact that there are many different faiths, many different colors and many different cultures in America is a great strength.”[23] He noted that "he has received hostile phone calls and e-mail messages along with some death threats. ...[but] emphasized that members of Congress and ordinary citizens had been overwhelmingly supportive and said he was focusing on setting up his Congressional office, getting phone lines hooked up and staff members hired, not on negative comments."[23]
In a Dec. 21, 2006 interview with CNN’s Wolf Blitzer, Ellison explained further "When I'm officially sworn in, I will do it the same exact way as every other congressperson-elect who was sworn in. We will all stand up and in unison lift our hand and swear to uphold that Constitution, and then later, in a private ceremony, of course I'll put my hand on a book that is the basis of my faith, which is Islam, and I think that this is a beauty -- this is a wonderful thing for our country because Jewish members will put their hands on the Torah. Mormon members will put their hand on the Book of Mormon. Catholic members will put their hand on the book of their choice -- and members they don't want to be put their hand on any book are also fully free to do that. That's the American way. ...I think the diversity of our country is a great strength. It's a good thing that we have people from all faiths and all cultures to come here." He responded to Goode's letter by saying that “he would like to meet with Goode to talk about Islam and find some ‘common ground. We all support one Constitution, one Constitution that upholds our right to equal protection, one Constitution that guarantees us due process under the law, one Constitution which says there is no religious test for elective office in America.’”[12] When asked if he thought Rep. Goode was a bigot, Ellison said "I don't know the fellow, and I'd rather just say that he has a lot to learn about Islam. ... I don't want to start any name-calling."[26] Ellison said he “looks forward to meeting Goode. ‘What I'd tell him is that there might be a few things about Muslims that he might want to know. He might want to know that Muslims -- there are about 5 million in the country -- that they are here to support and strengthen America. They are nurses, doctors, husbands, wives, kids, who just want to live and prosper in the American way and that there's really nothing to fear. And that all of us are steadfastly opposed to the same people he is opposed to, which is the terrorists, so there is nothing to be afraid of. And, that what we should do is to tell our constituents -- we should reach to each other and not be against each other and we should find ways for common ground.’”[ |
Esgalglinion - January 4, 2007 07:10 AM (GMT)
Hang on. Some people got mad at this muslim swearing on the Koran during this case? Wow. Your country is falling apart. :P
I Have a Sandwich - January 4, 2007 07:11 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Esgalglinion @ Jan 4 2007, 02:10 AM) |
| Hang on. Some people got mad at this muslim swearing on the Koran during this case? Wow. Your country is falling apart. :P |
Oh yeah? Well we have nukes. Beat that XD
Anyways, I don't see the problem in it. If he swears over his own holy book, he's more likely to keep his word I'd assume (if he was a devout muslim, of course).
Severian - January 4, 2007 08:34 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Esgalglinion @ Jan 4 2007, 02:10 AM) |
| Hang on. Some people got mad at this muslim swearing on the Koran during this case? Wow. Your country is falling apart. :P |
Ya, 30 years ago he wouldn't even be IN america! The only muslims we had were the NOI, and we had our foot on them!!
Ok, I'm being sarcastic. Look, we're slow at this stuff, esgal. It's the tradeoff for being the best country in the world. We're slow to improve at all :(
Esgalglinion - January 4, 2007 09:15 AM (GMT)
I was merely joking around. But I think you understood that. :P
What? You had muslims in America 30 years ago?! :o
Durendal - January 4, 2007 06:47 PM (GMT)
Don't even get me started on Americans. Best country in the world, BAH! You voted for Bush, MULTIPLE TIMES. 'Nuff said.
Severian - January 4, 2007 09:09 PM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Esgalglinion @ Jan 4 2007, 04:15 AM) |
I was merely joking around. But I think you understood that. :P
What? You had muslims in America 30 years ago?! :o |
Ya. Black ones, they belonged to the Nation of Islam. Malik El-Shabazz/Malcolm X, Mohammed Ali, Elijah Mohammed, etc. One could argue whether they were muslims in any sense we recognize, since they didn't read the qoran AFAIK or make the Hajj for a good deal of time, didn't think Muhammed was the final prophet, had a doctrinal hatred towards jews, and believed their founder was a messiah and embodiment of god, which is pretty Christian. An exception is Malcolm, who broke from the movement a few years from his death, embraced the entirety of the religion, and started preaching that Islam could bring everyone together, not just black people. They shot him :(
I'm sure we had some arab muslims too, but I've never really read anything about em.
| QUOTE |
| Don't even get me started on Americans. Best country in the world, BAH! You voted for Bush, MULTIPLE TIMES. 'Nuff said. |
I didn't :( My state favored Kerry, who's marginally better. And I wouldn't have if I was old enough to.
But you know, we're like that city on the hill or something, a beacon to you uncivilized european nations. Some preacher said it a couple hundred years ago, it's gotta be nearly as true as the constitution of the USA, which is apparently holy and infalliable due to being written by the guys who beat England or something.
Durendal - January 4, 2007 09:12 PM (GMT)
Uncivilized European Nations? Are you crazy? You know that Americans come from Europe right? Those "Uncivilized European Nations" were building huge colonies all around the world before America was anything but a mostly empty continent.
Kaden - January 4, 2007 10:07 PM (GMT)
It's her religion, and you can choose that here, I don't see what the big deal is.
I mean, they're worried about what she's sworn in on when they should be worried about Iraq, Iran, and North Korea.
As for uncivilized European nations... Just France, the rest are pretty civilized. My dad told me about when he was in France for the army, he said he went all over Europe, and the only time the were disrespected was in France. Two of his guys got kicked out of the army because the beat up a french dude for spitting in their faces. >_>
Valter - January 5, 2007 12:27 AM (GMT)
Silly Americans, always attacking what they don't understand.
Like Muslims and Saddam Hussein.
Kaden - January 5, 2007 12:43 AM (GMT)
Muslims are people, and just like most social groups everywhere, a few nutjobs can give them a bad image.
I Have a Sandwich - January 5, 2007 01:30 AM (GMT)
And Saddam was a psycopathic douschebag. I think we understand em.
My state favored Bush, and I'm fuckin proud of that. I favor Bush, and I still fuckin do. You have a problem, just let me say I really don't care. I'm not one for politics, especially among my peers. We are a generation whos political beliefs are not created by politics but by t-shirts and television programs. Damn near sickening.
Severian - January 5, 2007 02:10 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Durendal @ Jan 4 2007, 04:12 PM) |
| Uncivilized European Nations? Are you crazy? You know that Americans come from Europe right? Those "Uncivilized European Nations" were building huge colonies all around the world before America was anything but a mostly empty continent. |
Dear sir...how severely impaired is your ability to read the sarcastic tone of my post? I'm not really so snobby as to claim the US is the best country in the world. I like it ok but I haven't lived in many countries, so it'd be ignorant to crown a "best" on the basis of my knowledge.
The stuff about city on a hill and uncivilized europeans was just a reference to John Winthrop, a famous puritan speaker. Again, joke. The writer was against England's anglican church and the roman catholic church, and was hoping that the colonies in the new world succeed and serve as an example for the european nations. Of course, one could easily argue puritanism wasn't exactly the best religion to branch from Christianity, but...
| QUOTE |
| My state favored Bush, and I'm fuckin proud of that. I favor Bush, and I still fuckin do. You have a problem, just let me say I really don't care. I'm not one for politics, especially among my peers. We are a generation whos political beliefs are not created by politics but by t-shirts and television programs. Damn near sickening. |
So you're not one for politics, but you begrudge people who don't understand every facet politics and base decisions partially on trivial matters? I really don't care who you voted for, but I'm confused about your latter points.
EDIT: First off, I'm just curious, Valter, are you saying we don't get muslims, or they don't get us? I could see either as a possible statement.
| QUOTE |
| As for uncivilized European nations... Just France, the rest are pretty civilized. My dad told me about when he was in France for the army, he said he went all over Europe, and the only time the were disrespected was in France. Two of his guys got kicked out of the army because the beat up a french dude for spitting in their faces. >_> |
The Balkans ain't that civilized.
I Have a Sandwich - January 5, 2007 03:27 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE |
| So you're not one for politics, but you begrudge people who don't understand every facet politics and base decisions partially on trivial matters? I really don't care who you voted for, but I'm confused about your latter points. |
Lemme rephrase: I'm not one to partake in political discussions often, and even less often among my own peers because more often than not they don't think about what they're saying, they just spout what they're read on t-shirts and heard from comedians. I could care less if you understand or don't understand the facets of politics, it's just frustrating when people spout opinions that they're told to have, not what they're own opinions (If you can understand that).
Sorry bout that. I'm missing a lot of sleep, and I'm starting to notice I'm a lot less... coherent in the delivery of my thoughts today. Especially in the topic about the new RPG world.
Valter - January 5, 2007 01:04 PM (GMT)
Americans don't understand the Muslims.
Phoenix - January 6, 2007 12:20 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Durendal @ Jan 4 2007, 01:47 PM) |
| Don't even get me started on Americans. Best country in the world, BAH! You voted for Bush, MULTIPLE TIMES. 'Nuff said. |
I quite agree.
I am even more ashamed as a Virginian than when we voted for the amendment to "protect marriage".... And I am not talking about one to outlaw divorce.
I Have a Sandwich - January 6, 2007 06:16 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (Phoenix @ Jan 5 2007, 07:20 PM) |
| QUOTE (Durendal @ Jan 4 2007, 01:47 PM) | | Don't even get me started on Americans. Best country in the world, BAH! You voted for Bush, MULTIPLE TIMES. 'Nuff said. |
I quite agree.
I am even more ashamed as a Virginian than when we voted for the amendment to "protect marriage".... And I am not talking about one to outlaw divorce.
|
It really pisses me off when people say they're ashamed to call themselves "Such and such." If you're ashamed of it, either do something to change it or leave. Complaining and so-called witty remarks gets nothing.
Esgalglinion - January 6, 2007 04:09 PM (GMT)
Edit: Nevermind, what I said made no sense at all.
Severian - January 10, 2007 04:36 AM (GMT)
| QUOTE (ZeroKirbyX @ Jan 4 2007, 10:27 PM) |
| Lemme rephrase: I'm not one to partake in political discussions often, and even less often among my own peers because more often than not they don't think about what they're saying, they just spout what they're read on t-shirts and heard from comedians. I could care less if you understand or don't understand the facets of politics, it's just frustrating when people spout opinions that they're told to have, not what they're own opinions (If you can understand that). |
Got it, and agreed. And I'll admit, I've found that libs have a greater frequency to do so than conservatives. I think this is partially because lib is "in" with hollywood and such.